Been shopping for a Potty Training Dolls? How many different ones have you found? Have you tried comparing them? Since, I do this for a living, here is the comparison of the features, function and price by category of doll. You can also find a side by side comparison of all these potty training dolls, plus you can now purchase on these potty training dolls right here! I have tried to be as objective as I can, but you know that I do have a slight bias!! So, I would love to hear your thoughts on the comparison. |
Potty Scotty™ - Drink & wet-on-demand™ & Specially Designed to Potty Train™ using the Dr. Phil Potty Train in One Day method. Scotty can drink sitting up or laying down AND he can also pee standing up or sitting down - in any potty or toilet. Comes with a Parent's Potty Training Guide: "How to Potty Train in One Day" which is based on my experience, as well as the collective experiences of all the moms that used these dolls. Includes"big kid" underwear for the doll as recommended by Dr. Phil. Price: $49.95 |  
Potty Elmo It's Potty Time Bear
Stuffed toys as potty dolls.
These dolls do not drink water and do not go potty. When using these dolls, you and your child pretends to make the doll drink water and pretends to make the doll go potty.
These do dolls sing and make potty time fun and there is no messes with water These dolls come in different versions, with a teddy bear being the most popular; however other versions are also available - with a singing Potty Elmo being the most recent addition to these types of dolls. The concept you want to teach your child is to associate a feeling of fullness with the result i.e. urination. These dolls will only communicate this conceptually. Price: $20 - $30 |
Potty Patty™ - Drink & wet-on-demand™ & Specially Designed to Potty Train™ using the Dr. Phil Potty Train in One Day method. Patty can drink sitting up or laying down. She can pee in any potty. Comes with a Parent's Potty Training Guide: "How to Potty Train in One Day" which is based on my experience, as well as the collective experiences of all the moms that used these dolls. Includes"big kid" underwear for the doll as recommended by Dr. Phil. Price: $49.95 | 
A "drink & wet" doll Shown above are the aquini potty dolls; they can drink water, but cannot hold the water. Basically, these type of drink and wet dolls have a tube from the mouth to the bottom, so when you give the dolls water, it comes out right away. It is extremely hard to simulate the going potty behavior with these dolls. The girl version of these type of drink and wet dolls are readily available at a great price at stores such as Walmart & Target. The only anatomically correct boy version of this doll is the boy aquini potty doll. It is a little harder to come by, but can be found online and at specialty toy stores. Price: $8 - $30 |
Corolle Potty Potty Training Dolls
Drink and hold, until you want them to go potty. (have to drink water laying down or they will leak) These play dolls have been on the market for some time, but Dr. Phil with his shows on Potty Train in One Day has created a much higher demand for these dolls.
The girl versions of these dolls are more readily available. The anatomically correct boy potty training dolls are a little harder to find. Price: $35-$45 | 
Little Mommy Potty Training Doll
Drink and hold, until you want them to go potty. This doll will drink water and only potty in the potty that comes with the doll. Based on feedback from other moms, she is a little hard to feed and the whole doll is made of hard plastic. She does come in an african american version. Price: $20-$30 |
